Quick Search

705 Use of untreated billet connections in precast concrete structures

Report ID: 705

Published: Newsletter 54 - April 2019

Report Overview

Whilst completing a third-party design appraisal, a correspondent found that solid steel billets intended to form the primary shear transfer mechanism between concrete beams and columns were insufficient for this purpose.

Report Content

Whilst completing a third-party (CAT3) appraisal of a large external precast concrete structure subject to dynamic and fatigue loads, it was identified that the beam to column connections were formed using solid steel billet pieces which were inserted into sleeves and pockets cast into the side of the columns. The billets were fabricated from untreated steel plate, which was then protected using grout poured into the beam/column interface pockets at completion of the works.

The billets were intended to form the primary shear transfer mechanism between the beams and columns. However, further analysis indicated they were insufficient for this purpose and additional support columns were introduced which rendered the billet connection as a temporary support only.

The concern is that in structures subject to dynamic or fatigue forces, the poured grout will be susceptible to cracking and over time will lead to water ingress and corrosion of the billet. This raises associated long-term concerns of corrosion, spalling and in the extreme potential failure of the connected parts. Guidance from the precast concrete designer suggested this detail was commonplace in precast structures, hence there is a risk that this in-built corrosion trap will exist in other exposed precast structures.

Comments

Off-site manufacture, including the use of structural precast concrete elements, places considerable reliance on connections. For major bridge works, a design life of 120 years is not uncommon so all elements must be capable of operating satisfactorily for that time span. Because of the embedded positions of billets, repair or replacement would be extremely difficult. As noted by the reporter, fatigue and corrosion resistance need to be considered at the design stage for all elements including billets and their immediate surroundings.

For some building structures, such as car parks, billets have been used for years in connections between precast joints. Whilst subject to cyclical thermal loading and vibration, joints in car parks are however usually given a reasonable amount of weather protection by virtue of location and waterproofing surfacing on roofs. References to such connections can be found in various texts; for example The Concrete Centre publication Design of Hybrid Concrete Buildings and the Temporary Works Forum publication Precast concrete - good practice and common issues in temporary works.

Any evidence of corrosion or other problems arising from the use of billets would be welcomed by CROSS.

 

CROSS depends on you for reports - if you have experienced a safety issue that you can share with CROSS, please Submit a CROSS Report which is treated as confidential

If you have any comments regarding this CROSS report, please Submit Feedback

View other CROSS reports published in Newsletter 54


Email Updates

How to Report

Online submission:
Submit by post: