Quick Search

727 Questionable tension bracing arrangement

Report ID: 727

Published: Newsletter No 51 - July 2018

Report Overview

A reporter is concerned about the arrangement of diagonal tension bracing in one bay of a building.

Report Content

A reporter is concerned about the arrangement of diagonal tension bracing in one bay of a building. The connection is formed of 4 stainless steel bars connected by what looks to be a circular plate. The bars are out of alignment due to incorrect measurement or poor fabrication. To make the connection fit, the ends of the bars have been ground down and the plate skewed resulting in an eccentric loading arrangement.

In the case of a brace under tension, the plate will rotate about its centroid due to the eccentricity of the tension force. The resulting rotation will force the opposing bars into compression increasing the likelihood of the bars buckling - all the more critical if the length of the bars is not as designed.

Comments

Another case of a third party picking up on a potential fault. The arrangement of the members is not unusual, but it seems to be a case of the installation not matching the design, and possibly the assumptions in design being breached. No connection is perfect in alignment, but a good robust design will cater for some deviations.

If the members have needed to be altered on site to make them fit, that should have been the trigger to ensure the design was still valid. Any steel structure is only as good, or as safe, as the integrity of its connections. Hence the Principal Designer must be assured that the design intent overall has been correctly translated into reality.

However, has the reporter raised this with the building owner? There is no legal duty to do so but as a matter of good ethical practice an engineer who notices a potential safety issue would advise the owner, or tenant of their concern. If it is not known who this is, then the local authority could be informed. Where there might be an immediate and severe risk, then CROSS may be able to advise on a course of action.

 

CROSS depends on you for reports - if you have experienced a safety issue that you can share with CROSS, please Submit a CROSS Report

If you have any comments regarding this CROSS report, please Submit Feedback

View other CROSS reports published in Newsletter No. 51


Email Updates

How to Report

Online submission:
Submit by post: